Wellington's Rating Policies Review (2026): From Capital Value to Land Value
Wellington City Council is consulting from 19 October to 15 November 2026 on moving its general rates from capital value to land value, alongside a cut in the commercial differential and a wider vacant-land differential. No decision has been made.
Overview
From 19 October to 15 November 2026, Wellington City Council is consulting on five proposed changes to its rating policies.[2] The first asks whether the general rate should be set on land value instead of capital value, the base used "since the late 1990s".[1] Land value excludes "the value of houses, apartments, commercial buildings and other improvements".[1] The Council's planning and finance committee identified consulting on that move as its preferred option in June 2026. Two other proposals bear on the same question: cutting the commercial differential from 3.7:1 to 3.0:1 over six years, and extending the area covered by the 5.0× vacant-land and derelict-building differential.[1]
No decision has been made. The Council "may decide to proceed with all, some, or none of the proposals, or make other changes".[7] Everything below describes a proposal under consultation, as at 23 October 2026.
How the Proposal Arose
On 25 June 2026, Te Taurapa | Council Planning and Finance Committee considered officers' report on rating changes for the 2027-37 Long-term Plan. It resolved to "consult on changing the rating base for general rates to Land Value (LV) from Capital Value (CV)", labelled "Option 2 [preferred]", by 16 votes to 2; the alternative was to discontinue the review.[3][4] On 1 October 2026 it adopted the consultation document by 13 votes to 3, adding the statement that "Retaining the status quo, or other differentials are also viable options".[1][5]
The Council's stated reason is that land value rating "may encourage land to be developed and used more efficiently", since owners "do not pay higher general rates simply because they build new homes".[1] It adds that advocates argue the base "can discourage land banking and under-utilisation", cites a 2015 Productivity Commission view that councils should consider its merits, and says land value is "a better proxy for income than capital value".[1] The document also records the case for capital value: higher-value properties are said to place greater demands on services.[1]
The Council is candid about the limits of its evidence. It "cannot model any increased development, reduced land banking, or increased housing supply" from the switch, "due to a lack of other Councils of similar size undertaking such a transition recently".[6] The efficiency rationale is therefore a stated expectation, not a modelled result.
What Would Change
- General rates on land value. Total revenue would not change; the burden would be redistributed. Sites with high land value and little development "could pay a greater share", intensively developed sites "a smaller share", outdoor car parks would pay more, and utilities "could pay considerably less" because much of their capital value is infrastructure.[1] The sector and Downtown targeted rates would stay on capital value.[1]
- Who gains and loses. A presentation tabled on 25 June reported modelling in which about 60% of residential ratepayers would be better off, mainly in inner-city apartments and the outer suburbs, and about 80% of commercial ratepayers worse off, "mainly driven by utilities benefitting".[4]
- The commercial multiple. Holding the current 51:49 residential–commercial split under land value would need a commercial differential of about 5.8; the document's examples assume the split continues.[1]
- Cutting the differential (a separate proposal). On 2026/27 rates, moving from 3.7:1 to 3.0:1 would reduce the general rate on an average $1.5 million downtown commercial property from $18,280 to $16,704 and raise that on a $1.5 million residential property from $4,460 to $4,861; these figures are on the existing capital-value base. The Council notes it "remains uncertain" whether landlords would pass a reduction on to tenants.[1]
- Vacant land. The inner-city differential introduced in the 2024-34 Long-term Plan charges 5.0 times the base general rate. The proposal extends it to undeveloped property along Adelaide Road, including around the Basin Reserve and up to Wellington Regional Hospital.[1] Officers had described such an extension as a possible "limited alternative to a land value rating system".[3]
- Cost. Implementing land value rating is estimated at $600,000 to $2 million, met through rates.[1]
The consultation document illustrates the shift with seven hypothetical rating units, holding the residential–commercial split at 51:49 with a 5.8 commercial differential and showing estimated 2026/27 Council rates (GST included, excluding water, regional council and sludge charges) under each base:[1]
| Rating unit | Capital value base | Land value base |
|---|---|---|
| Hillside house, 1 unit | $3,351 | $3,714 |
| Apartment building, 39 units | $37,958 | $35,095 |
| Residential, 1 unit | $4,309 | $3,626 |
| Residential duplex, 2 units | $4,446 | $5,437 |
| Mixed use, 5 units | $16,752 | $16,430 |
| Industrial/commercial, 1 unit | $33,487 | $82,748 |
| CBD mixed use, 27 units | $73,041 | $56,767 |
The direction is as the Council describes: dense buildings on valuable land pay less, and a single-unit industrial site on a large plot pays far more.
The National Context
The consultation document reports that 65 per cent of New Zealand councils (51 of 78) rate on capital value in 2026, against 58 per cent ten years earlier and 50 per cent twenty years earlier; Porirua, Hutt City and Upper Hutt use capital value.[1][4] A briefing slide lists Hutt City, Palmerston North and Thames-Coromandel among recent moves towards capital value.[4]
That fits the longer record on the New Zealand page. Its figures (29 per cent of councils on land value in 2019) come from a different analysis and are not combined with the Council's series here. The best-known test of the base, Auckland's 2010 amalgamation, found little effect on new building when councils moved the other way; see Gemmell, Grimes and Skidmore. On who would pay, the nearest New Zealand evidence is a 2009 Motu study by Andrew Coleman and Arthur Grimes, which modelled a national land tax rather than council rating and found that because land values rise more steeply with household income than capital values do, "a land tax is more progressive (for households) than is a property tax", with the caveat that the overall distributional result depends on which taxes are reduced in exchange.[12]
Timeline
- 19 October to 15 November 2026: consultation; oral hearings in November.[1][8]
- December 2026: after analysing feedback, the committee votes on whether "all, some, or none of the five proposals" go forward.[8][9]
- March-April 2027: formal consultation on the draft 2027-37 Long-term Plan (a Council release says April).[5][9]
- June 2027: Long-term Plan adoption.[3]
- 1 July 2027: the earliest effect, and "only if the Council adopts" the changes after that process.[1] A transition plan, possibly phased, would be considered in the Plan.[1][6]
The Council flags regional amalgamation as a risk: officers advised that "it may not be the right time" to diverge from neighbouring councils that rate on capital value.[3]
Relation to the Georgist Case
A capital city is consulting on reversing a drift that the New Zealand page records over some forty years. The Council's rationale, that a base excluding improvements does not penalise building and may discourage land banking, is the standard efficiency argument for split-rate taxation and the land value tax. The extended vacant-land differential is a use-based penalty on idle sites, a cruder cousin of the continuous incentive a land base provides; compare speculative vacancy.
This is a change of rating base for the general rate, not a new tax. Total revenue is unchanged, commercial land still pays at a differential, targeted rates stay on capital value, and the same consultation proposes lowering the commercial multiple.
Nuances and Limits
- Nothing is decided. The June "preferred" label applies to consulting on the change, not to adopting it; the Council's FAQ says "No decision has yet been made".[8]
- The modelling is illustrative. The 60% and 80% figures come from a tabled presentation, not a published study, and the Council states that key modelling will be subject to peer review.[4][10] The dollar examples above are the Council's own hypothetical rating units, not a sample of actual properties.
- Legal basis. The Council states that general rates are set under section 13 of the Local Government (Rating) Act 2002.[11] The Productivity Commission observed in 2019 that councils other than Auckland may choose land value under current law (see New Zealand).
- Advocates. Common Ground Aotearoa, an advocacy group named in the 25 June minutes as a participant and proponent, is mentioned as the origin of advocacy for the change only, not as evidence for it.[4]
See Also
- New Zealand
- Gemmell, Grimes and Skidmore on the Auckland Amalgamation
- Split-Rate Taxation
- Land Value Tax
- Speculative Vacancy
- Land Banking
- The 2026 State LVT Enablement Wave
Sources
- Wellington City Council, Rating Policies Review: Consultation Document (approved October 2026), pp. 3–25. letstalk.wellington.govt.nz — used for the five proposals, the late-1990s capital-value base, the Council's stated reasons and counter-arguments, the 65/58/50 per cent series, the high-level impacts, the 5.8 differential note, the $18,280/$16,704 and $4,460/$4,861 examples, the $600,000–$2 million cost, the 5.0× vacant-land differential and Adelaide Road extension, and the consultation dates (A-claim for proposals and stated reasons; B-claim for modelled effects, which are the Council's own and illustrative; the causal claim that land value rating encourages development is a stated expectation, D-claim). The seven hypothetical rating units are from the figure on p. 14.
- Wellington City Council, Rating Policies Review hub and summary document, 2026. letstalk.wellington.govt.nz/rating-policies-review — used for the five-proposal structure (A-claim).
- Wellington City Council, Te Taurapa | Council Planning and Finance Committee, supplementary agenda, 25 June 2026, item A.1, "Proposed rating policy changes for Consultation to inform the 2027-37 LTP". — used for officers' reasoning on the vacant-land extension, the amalgamation caution, the limit to general rates and the June 2027 adoption (A-claim as a statement of officer advice).
- Wellington City Council, Minutes of Te Taurapa | Council Planning and Finance Committee, 25 June 2026, item A.1 and tabled presentation. — used for the "Option 2 [preferred]" resolution and the 16:2 vote, the 3.0:1 preferred commercial option, the 65 per cent (51 of 78) slide, the recent-switches slide, the ~60 per cent and ~80 per cent modelling bullets, and the Common Ground Aotearoa note (A-claim for resolutions; B-claim for the modelling slide, which is not a published study; Common Ground is Tier 2, origin/proponent only).
- Wellington City Council, Minutes of Te Taurapa | Council Planning and Finance Committee, 1 October 2026, item 2.2. — used for adoption of the consultation document (13:3), the amendments, and the March–April 2027 formal consultation (A-claim).
- Wellington City Council, Te Taurapa | Council Planning and Finance Committee, councillor questions and answers, 1 October 2026. — used for the statement that development, land-banking and housing-supply effects cannot be modelled, and for 1 July 2027 and transition advice (A-claim as to what the Council states).
- Wellington City Council, news release, "Wellington's rating policy review – have your say", 20 October 2026. wellington.govt.nz — used for the five proposals, "all, some, or none" and the position that no decisions have been made (A-claim).
- Wellington City Council, Rating Policies Review hub timeline and FAQ, 2026. letstalk.wellington.govt.nz/rating-policies-review — used for the timeline (oral hearings in November, analysis, December decision) and the FAQ statement that no decision has been made to change the rating basis (A-claim).
- Wellington City Council, news release, "Wellington's rating policy – have your say", 1 October 2026. wellington.govt.nz — used for the December vote on whether all, some or none of the five proposals proceed, and the April 2027 Long-term Plan consultation (A-claim).
- Wellington City Council, Te Taurapa | Council Planning and Finance Committee, agenda, 1 October 2026, item 2.2 report. — used for the statement that key modelling will be subject to peer review (A-claim).
- Wellington City Council, Te Taurapa | Council Planning and Finance Committee, agenda, 25 June 2026, Revenue and Financing Policy extract. — used for the statement that general rates are set under section 13 of the Local Government (Rating) Act 2002; the statutory text itself is not cited (A-claim as to the Council's own statement).
- Andrew Coleman & Arthur Grimes (2009), Fiscal, Distributional and Efficiency Impacts of Land and Property Taxes, Motu Working Paper 09-14, Motu Economic and Public Policy Research, September 2009. motu.nz — used for the household-progressivity finding (printed p. 36) and the life-cycle and offsetting-tax caveat (p. 45) (B-claim; unrefereed working paper by Tier 1 economists, partly Treasury-funded; its scenario is a national land tax, not a change of rating base).