New York Times on the Ignorance of the Experts
|May 16, 2014||Posted by Staff under Editorials|
This 2014 excerpt of the New York Times, Apr 18, is of a book review by Howard W. French.
“The Tyranny of Experts: Economists, Dictators, and the Forgotten Rights of the Poor” is by William Easterly who describes himself as a recovering expert, referring to his career at the World Bank.
“The technocratic approach ignores what this book will establish as the real cause of poverty — the unchecked power of the state against poor people without rights,” he writes. He cites African land grabs.
Easterly’s other major claim is that technocratic advisers attach little importance to the historical background of the countries they work on. He offers the example of the World Bank, in 1949, whipping up a 950-page development plan for Colombia in less than a year, in which recommendations weren’t specific to that country.
He claims paternalism and a belief in the incapacity of others is an unexamined foundation of development ideology.
He touts Adam Smith who understood that not all problems could be solved by the Invisible Hand of the market and describes Hayek as a fierce proponent of individual liberty who favored a minimum income guaranteed by the state and attacked British Conservatives as “paternalistic.”
The greatest benefits to a society come from the spontaneous, uncoordinated actions of mostly small actors whose talents are allowed to flourish, as opposed to top-down initiatives involving the state or outside donors.
Ed. Notes: To shake any remaining faith in so-called experts, check out
- UK Scientists Request Out-of-the-Box Thinking and
- Rethinking Aid in Africa and
- Development can happen about two-thirds of the way down and
- half of academic articles are not true and
- wrongs results being non-self-correcting.