Bundy’s ATVs Ride Over Sacred Navaho Land in Utah
|June 7, 2014||Posted by Staff under Land Disputes|
Prior to a large and illegal ATV – or All Terrain Vehicle (something none of the riders invented, nor their rifles, nor the sewing machines that made their cowboy outfits) – ride through Recapture Canyon in Utah, there had been a great deal of criticism and concern from the Navajo Nation. The ride through Recapture Canyon would put thousands of years of cultural resources for Native Americans at risk, not to mention that the ride also went over an ancient and sacred Native American burial ground. But the riders ignored federal law and religious rights.
Some of the ATV-riding law breakers in Utah this weekend were members of the Cliven Bundy camp. In an email blast to his “followers,” Bundy wrote that, “We need to help the people of Blanding re-establish who is in control of the land. This is your next stand. Will you be there to help them like you helped us?”
While Bundy’s call to his followers to illegally ride on government land and put thousands of years’ worth of history and culture at risk is deplorable, it’s a symptom of a much larger problem in America, a problem which has been around since Columbus first sailed the ocean blue. If the culture isn’t White and European-based, much of white America pretty much doesn’t give a damn about it.
Ed. Notes: First Bundy and his followers refused to respect public land, next was sacred land. They still believe that might makes right and land is there for the taking. While they are petty and selfish and threaten violence, they are not much different from land-greedy groups elsewhere in America, everywhere on the planet, and all through human history.
While they are in the wrong, part of the blame falls on conventional society for not making clear the nature of property. Land becomes property only when the occupant or wannabe owner compensates those whom he excludes — his nearby neighbors. All of us have an equal right to life, none of us can live without land, so we all have an equal right to Earth.
Bundy, his followers, and many others despise this notion of paying rent to their community. But they shouldn’t. Not just because morally we all are obliged to compensate those whom we exclude from a part of Earth. But also because, bottom line, they can’t lose. As members of the community, they’ll be getting compensated, too. Everybody would pay land dues into the public treasury and get rent dividends back. Owners of land of average value or less — as are most of Bundy’s followers — would get back more than they pay. With a happy wallet, all they’d have to mollify is their egos about being renters to their neighbors.