

The Solution to the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict
Isaiah 59:8 tells us, "The way of peace, they know not."
Events are hurling Israel/Palestine down a spiral to ever more
fearsome conflict. Suicide bombers wrecked terror to disrupt the
peace process, killing 14 Israelis in Jerusalem. Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu accused Arafat's government of not
doing enough to curb terrorism and arrest those responsible. The
Israeli government shut the border, banned travel by Palestinians,
and withholds tax revenues that pay the government workers in
Palestine. The Palestinian authority in turn has retaliated.
Yasser Arafat's government now threatens to boycott Israeli
products.
Why have terrorists on both sides sought to stop "the way of
peace?" Because they don't like the direction it is taking.
Extremist Israeli Jews insist that the West Bank should remain part
of Israel, as its historic Samaria and Judea. Extremist
Palestinian Arabs demand total possession of the West Bank, and
then the rest of Israel as rightfully Arab. The heart of the
conflict is land: two peoples claim to own the same piece of
territory. Splitting the land and separating the two peoples is
difficult because the populations are now intermingled, Israeli
Jews having resettled the Judea-Samaria West Bank, and Palestinian
Arabs having become dependent on jobs in Israel.
The problem with the peace process is that the two sides set
forth on a path whose destination was unknown. Without a known
goal, fearing the worst, extremists on both sides have sought to
halt the process with violence, and they succeeded in derailing the
caravan to peace. What is needed is a clear destination, and one
that satisfies the desire of both sides for justice. Most Israelis
and Palestinians are willing to co-exist, but only if they feel the
ultimate settlement does not betray their quest for a homeland.
But how can two peoples justly occupy the same land? The main
principle of justice is equality. Each side should recognize that
the other has a just and equal claim to live in Israel/Palestine.
The just solution to the land question is to endow each resident of
the territory an equal claim to the land.
To implement an equal share of the land, it is not necessary
to reassign the land titles, or force people to move. There is no
need to physically redivide the land itself, but rather the
benefits of the land. And the benefits of the land are manifested
in the value of the land, which can be measured by the rent that
people are willing to pay to be located in the land.
The solution to the land question in Israel/Palestine is to
make each Israeli and Palestinian resident a common owner of all
the land there, and then to have each person that possesses land
pay rent to the people as owners. The more valuable land one side
occupies, the more rent it will have to pay. Land would be held at
a price. A market for land would replace the conflict over land.
To whom would the rent be paid? Certainly not to the Israeli
or the Palestinian governments. Instead, there could be a
confederation of the two governments. The rent would be paid to
the confederation, which would then allocate some of it to the two
governments and use some of it for common territorial services,
such as environmental protection. The confederation could also
have courts to resolve disputes between Israelis and Palestinians,
and also have authority over common resources such as water.
The concept of sharing the land was recognized by the
religious philosopher, Martin Buber, who settled in Israel. In a
1956 article, "Socialism and Peace," Buber wrote that the only
thing that can bring about peace in Israel is "a just distribution
of the soil, and the formulation of small communities which would
be organic cells of this new economy and this new society" (A Land
of Two Peoples, 1983). But he said he had no blueprint of how to
bring this about. Economics offers the blueprint: a just
distribution of the rent of the soil, because the rent can be
easily collected and divided.
If this economic solution can be made known, discussed, and
then implemented, then the Israelis and the Palestinians can set
forth together on an upward spiral to living together in peace.
With a known and just destination, then those extremists will not
be able to disrupt the peace process, because the two peoples will
have already settled on a just solution.