Government Gives Land Away to Special Favorites, Without Bidding, At Below-Market Price
LAND SALE TO CATHOLIC CHURCH IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL 'SWEETHEART DEAL,' SAYS CHURCH-STATE WATCHDOG GROUP
A plan by government officials in Pueblo West, Colo., to sell a parcel of land to a Roman Catholic church for a fraction of its value raises serious First Amendment concerns, says Americans United for Separation of Church and State.(Publisher's note -- an organization called Americans United has found a surprise: the government selling land to whoever it wants, without bidding, at below-market prices! Unless we put an early stop to it, this will rapidly become a new categpory of corporate welfare, of the very worst kind. Americans United is worried that the buyer is a church -- well, we're no better off if the government gives the land to Wal-Mart or Exxon either! Let's try to find leaders who truly prefer free markets, not as a campaign slogan but as an actual policy.)
"This arrangement smacks of a sweetheart deal," said Barry W. Lynn, executive director of Americans United. "Government may not give religious groups this type of financial benefit."
The controversy centers around 8.4 acres of municipal land next to St. Paul the Apostle Church. The church has been attempting to buy the land since 1995. At that time, the land was worth $11,600. It is now valued at $200,000. Under an agreement struck with city officials, the church will get the land for the 1995 price.
In a letter faxed today to city officials, Americans United Litigation Counsel Ayesha Khan warned that selling the land to the church without competitive bidding could spark legal problems for the city.
"We believe that the sale would constitute a gross violation of constitutional principles and we request that you reconsider your decision so as to avoid legal action," wrote Khan.
Lynn agreed and called on municipal officials to rescind the sale agreement. "Government cannot get into the business of granting special favors and preferential treatment to certain religious groups," he said. "It violates the separation of church and state and raises a host of problems."
Americans United is a 60,000-member public policy group based in Washington, D.C., that works to defend the constitutional principle of church-state separation.
Do you have an opinion on this? Tell The Progress Report:
Page One Page Two Archive Discussion Room Letters What's Geoism?